Should I Repair My Oven or Replace It?

The rule: the 50% Rule.

If the repair quote is half or more of what a new oven costs, replace it. Under half, repair it.

Ovens are among the longest-lived appliances in your kitchen — mostly a heating element, a thermostat, and a control board in a big insulated box. Most repairs are cheap: a $150 igniter or element on a 10-year-old oven is a no-brainer. The math only turns against repair when the bill gets big, usually a failed control board or a dead convection system.

Ovens last about 15 years — much longer than washers or dishwashers. Because they live so long, age rarely forces your hand: even a 12-year-old oven is usually worth a modest repair, since it may have years of life left.

Educational estimate only. Based on YOUR repair quote, cost of a comparable new oven, and age of your oven in years you enter. Uses 50% Rule: if repair is half or more of what a new oven costs, replace it. Under half and under about 15 years old, repair it. 15+ years old, replace it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 50% rule for ovens?

If the repair quote is half or more of what a new oven costs, replace it. Under half, repair it.

When should I replace instead of repairing?

If repair is over $500 or the oven is 15+ years old, replace it. Ovens last about 15 years — much longer than washers or dishwashers.

When is a repair worth it?

If repair is under $300 and the oven is under 10 years old, fix it — a $150 igniter on a 10-year-old oven is a no-brainer, since it may have years of life left.

When should I ignore this rule and talk to a professional?

This is educational only, not professional advice — get quotes from licensed, reputable contractors.

Not quite your situation?

Try one of these decisions instead:

• Should I Repair My Dishwasher or Replace It?
• Should I Repair My Washer or Buy a New One?
• Should I Repair My Dryer or Replace It?